Single inverted commas

Although it is usual to enclose a word under discussion in single inverted commas, I have chosen instead to emphasise it in red to prevent confusion with apostrophes.

Friday, 20 November 2026

The Friar: General Prologue to The Canterbury Tales

 The Friar also has a long portrait, as if Chaucer is determined to be accurate about the contemporary state of the church and not misrepresent it by curtailing his description. Huberd (one of the few named characters) is a begging friar, licensed to beg within a certain limited district. Because of this we see him actively cheating the public face to face which was not the case with the Prioress nor the Monk. On the downward drift throughout the General Prologue, he is not as venal as the ecclesiastics to follow: his is a mixed portrait. The satire deepens as Chaucer works through the people connected to the church. 

The rhyme at the end of the first line links him to the Monk ("merye/berye") perhaps indicating that we are on a sliding scale into  depravity. The word "wantown" could mean either "wanton" in the modern sense or "cheerful" and Chaucer probably intended both. "Solempne" has the sense of "important" rather than "serious" and The Friar is the most accomplished in familiar talk and fancy language of all the four orders (Dominicans, Franciscans, Carmelites, Augustines). 

The next detail is one that Chaucer could not have noticed in person: he switches between what he sees as pilgrim and what he knows either as omniscient narrator or has overheard in conversation. The Friar has paid for the marriages of many young women but this is less generous than it sounds because they would have been his former mistresses. As a support to his order, he is familiar and friendly with landholders and well-to-do women and is licensed to hear confessions. Here we can hear his own voice as he claims he has more power than a "curat". He has the knack of making both confession and absolution agreeable - which is not its true purpose. Clearly he cultivates affluent people for the large sum they would offer in return, emphasised by the rhyme "penaunce/pitaunce": they got off lightly in penances because they gave a lot of money. Again we can hear his mellifluous, lying and persuasive tone of voice every time he mentions the poverty of the order. The implication is that the more the person gives, the more thoroughly they are absolved. 

In the next lines the "he" needs explanation:

"For if he (the man confessing) yaf, he (the Friar) dorste make avaunt (assertion)

He (the Friar) wiste that a man was repentaunt. 

Irony pinpoints the next twist of logic, that a man may be so hard of heart that he cannot weep but can - instead of tears and prayers - give silver to the poor friars. By now the irony is sharp as they are clearly far from poor. His hood-like accessory is full of gifts for beautiful women. Immediately, Chaucer softens the Friar's hypocrisy, not directly, but by adding an appealing detail. He outshines everyone in singing traditional ballads and playing a small harp .

Quite suddenly, there is an unexpected physical detail which adds the contradiction of realism: his neck is white although he is very strong. In Medieval physiognomy, a white neck and a lisp (mentioned later) were signs of lasciviousness. He knows the inn-keepers and barmaids in every hostelry better than the sick lepers or beggar women. Here again, although the narrative is third person, the first person voice of the Friar breaks through, arguing that it does not look well or fit with his profession to mix with the lowly but with the wealthy and the sellers of food, anywhere that there was profit to be had. The rhythms are of the speaking man unctuously excusing himself whilst the ironic rhyme "poraille/vitaille" condemns him. We must remember that this work was conceived for an oral audience as it would be read aloud, books being very expensive. 

The Friar is humble, courteous and energetic (vertuous) when there was good begging to be done - which made him the best at it. Even if a poor widow had not a shoe, he could worm a coin out of her by intoning the opening words of the Gospel according to St. John. By this means, his perks amounted to more than his income. 

He could "rage" (romp or be wanton) like a puppy; the playful image here softens the severity of the accusation. On days appointed for legal settlements, he would be very helpful as umpire, presiding in fine clothing: a Master's degree conferred great dignity but also involved much expense. His short cloak (not a threadbare cape) rounded out like a bell out of the mould - another sudden visual detail interrupting the account of his dealings. He lisped out of affectation so that his speech was appealing. Now we are given an attractive ending to a largely critical portrait: when he had finished singing, his eyes twinkled like stars on a frosty night as he played his harp.  

Summary and method. As usual Chaucer intermingles (without warning) what he has learned of the character and what he sees before him. The Friar is meaner than the Monk but better than the Pardoner. He has charms and graces but he is - seemingly in realistic contradiction - as strong as a champion. His own voice breaks though the narration and spotlights his callous attitude to cheating the reverential poor and sick. He uses religion for his own ends and yet the portrait ends on an attractive note as we can easily form an active visual picture of Huberd singing, playing and twinkling. The word "worthy" is clearly strongly ironic - but it applies to the church also, that can consider such a man worthy and condone his practices. 

Monday, 16 November 2026

The Monk: General Prologue to The Canterbury Tales

 The Monk is the first of the male ecclesiastics to be portrayed and he is treated comparatively sympathetically here by Chaucer, being appealing in physical appearance and not depicted as cheating people face to face. 

He is introduced as a fine fellow whose duty was to look after the estates of his monastery, the church being rich in land. This meant he had to ride out but he used this as an excuse for hunting, which was a passion of his. This gives an ironic twist to the claim that he was worthy of being an abbot, since he was exceeding his role by engaging in worldly pursuits. However, a certain shrewdness was necessary for him to carry out his tasks. 

He owned many fine horses and the one he rode as a pilgrim had loudly jingling bridle bells. This is metonymy, whereby the health and vigour of the man is conveyed through something connected to him, his top condition, noticeable mount. Bells on a bridle were aspirational.

He was Prior to a strict subordinate religious house but he let the old-fashioned rules lapse and preferred the modern outlook. Here Chaucer captures a turning point in Medieval life. A vibrant phrase, "pulled hen" (plucked), captures his disdain for the Monk's belief that a hunter cannot be holy or that a monk outside his cloister is like a fish out of water. He disposes of any authoritative barriers to his worldly pleasures. The striking rhyme "cloystre/oystre" almost sounds like his derisive scoffing.

The next line: "And I seyde his opinioun was good" shows Chaucer using his persona of naif pilgrim to invite us to question the morality of a churchman who flouts the principles of asceticism and religious teaching so readily. The technique sharpens when the narrator takes on the voice of the character arguing that studiousness does no good and neither does hard toil. He derides St. Augustine and the scorn can be heard in the rhythm whilst he defends his disobedience by claiming that acceptance of the rules does not help anybody. The use of "therefore" suggests - erroneously - that it follows logically for the Monk to be a hard rider, owning swift greyhounds and dedicated to hunting hares, no matter what it cost. Here Chaucer, the narrator, is criticising indirectly but more strongly as the code of poverty is abandoned.

A sudden switch returns us to the present onlooker, observing face to face rather than recounting what he has learned. His eye alights on the grey fur trim on the Monk's sleeves, the finest skins in the country. Another visual detail is his love-brooch, skilfully made. Up goes the watchful eye to the shiny bald head and face, oily - but not unattractive because he is stout and in good condition. His eyes are prominent and active in a head that glows like a furnace under a cauldron. Down we go now to his quality, supple boots and outwards to his fine horse: the narrator's eye roves constantly noticing this and that.  The Monk is handsome and vibrant, not colourless (like a person wasted away by torment), enjoying a roasted fat swan best: the rhyme goost/roost makes the juxtaposed contrast stand out. The portrait ends quite abruptly with the mention of the type of horse he was riding - but the rhyme goes forwards to the next pilgrim with "berye/merye".

Summary and method. The Monk is rich, ample, expansive and pleasure-loving. He is the opposite of meanness and dryness: he shines, glows, steams and jangles. His belongings are of good quality and he has the feel of fresh air about him, not the cloister. These attributes, whilst appealing, are not religious: oblique criticism underlies the whole portrait. Yet some of the reproach is directed at the church for condoning such worldliness, even in a man whose duties are somewhat secular. We have the prototype method of giving the outline shape of the figure with details of features, clothing, colour (quite neutral), belongings, habits and, in this case almost the speaking voice along with the noise of bells. 

The portrait shows one of the best examples of Chaucer's use of his innocently observing persona with his apparent total trust in the Monk's values and opinions. 

Thursday, 12 November 2026

The Prioress: General Prologue to The Canterbury Tales

 The portrait of the Prioress is longer than many, except for the other ecclesiastics. As with them, Chaucer's satire is directed at the institution of the church, as well as at the individual, for overlooking or condoning lack of piety. His criticism of them is indirect and is of varying degrees of sharpness: he is relatively kind towards the Prioress. He gives her attractive physical features and fastidious habits and she is not seen as defrauding the public directly. The "religious" portraits tend to become more venomous as the Prologue continues, although not in any consistent manner.

Her quiet (not coy in our modern sense) smile is the first attribute mentioned in his typically unschematic description, followed by her mild oaths, which could be inappropriate, however genteel. She is one of the few pilgrims to be named and Chaucer soon moves on to her manners, some of which he could not have observed. He switches here between the naif witness and the omniscient narrator. She is somewhat pretentious, speaking French (but sub-Parisian) and adopting the table manners required at court or at a castle dinner table, keeping her food from falling onto her breast, wiping her top lip clean and reaching delicately for her food. It is clear that she is not a true aristocrat but she wishes to be seen as upper class - which is nothing to do with her position in the church. Chaucer is explicit in saying that she wanted to "countrefete" or imitate court manners, a harmless aspiration though irreligious.

She is slightly performative in her extreme sensibility, "conscience", weeping over a dead mouse or one of the dogs that she should not have been keeping as that was forbidden by the church - and they were far too well fed on roast meat and fine bread.

It is only towards the end that Chaucer describes her physical appearance in detail, making her so appealing that we tend to forgive her flaws. She is agreeably plump (he uses litotes here) with a long but well-shaped nose, a small, soft, red mouth and broad forehead visible under her neat wimple (which possibly should have covered more of it).This is her vanity and most of the characters have one, often less justifiable.

Another aspect of her pride in her appearance is her graceful cloak and she also wore a set of beads of which the 11th ones, the larger, were green Paternosters and the smaller were Ave Marias. A shiny gold brooch bore the Latin motto Amor Vincit Omnia - although it is uncertain if it is earthly or heavenly love that is designated as conquering all.

Summary and method, The Prioress is very feminine, almost girlish. and a welcome contrast to the preceding men; she also seems attuned to the indoors in her normal life. She has dainty affectations, is polished and civilised although she wishes to be thought of higher social status than she is, displaying a cultured, exaggerated and out-of-place sensibiility. Her flouting of the rules by keeping dogs, ensuring that her wimple is fluted, omitting a veil, are noted by Chaucer by his including them but his view is sympathetic - possibly because she does no overt cheating. Her foibles are discreet and her vanity harmless. As often, we are given an outline shape of her physical appearance with colourful and accurate details added.

Tuesday, 10 November 2026

The Squire and the Yeoman: General Prologue to The Canterbury Tales

 I have written about the Knight on a different blog, taking into account the critical view of Terry Jones, and will give the link here (there's a Search button to Knighthood in the Fourteenth Century). 

https://onthebusesm.blogspot.com

Next come the Squire and the Yeoman, short portraits and worth considering together since both accompany the Knight.

The Squire (a "bacheler", which was a rank in knighthood) is the son of the Knight and represents the younger generation. Whichever moral view you take of the Knight, he was somewhat out-of-date, colourless and shabby whereas the Squire is brightly hued and vibrant. Almost the first word used of him is "lover" and we see instantly from his curly hair (which looks as if it has been pressed) that he is a dandy. Yet he is strong and active.

The next detail, not one of observation, is ambiguous. He had taken part in extra expeditions on horseback and acquitted himself well. These could be sanctioned forages but could also be raids, although they might be seen as chivalrous by a lady. A simile comparing him to a meadow evokes his colourful freshness as he sings and plays the flute all day. He is talented in the social graces: he could compose songs, dance, joust, portray and write. As a lover, he is almost absurdly active, never sleeping. At the end is a sudden, rather unexpected touch to the portrait, a change of angle so that we see a different side to him. Carving at table was an honourable service and part of a Squire's duty, yet there is a humility about the act unseen in him as yet.

Summary and method. This is a portrait of the present generation but individualised as colourful youth, active, talented, dandyish yet robust and hearty, slightly artificial, wholesome and yet artistic. It is the contradictions that make him real and not stereotyped. His exterior, his intricate clothing, is a clue to his vanity by a loose form of metonymy. As always, the description is not schematic: hair, habits, experiences, clothing are apparently jumbled but the juxtaposition can be telling. His strength immediately precedes mention of the horseman's sallies into the countryside. 

The Yeoman is the only other companion to the Knight. Chaucer, under his naif persona, accepts the reason given that he preferred it like that. This character is of the outdoors, evoked by the green of his attire and the brown of his face and yet there is brighter colour in the peacock feathers of his arrows. Chaucer seems fascinated by his equipment and accessories, admiring the quality and how well it is all maintained.  There is always a positive note in his writing when a man or woman is skilled at their trade and this forester knows his woodcraft in detail and how to care for his arrow feathers.

The Yeoman is not aristocratic but is an open-air countryman, not polished like the Squire. There is no artificiality about him and his pride is in his equipment and expertise, not himself.

 Summary and method. Whilst it is an attractive presentation, he does seem very heavily armed for his trade: Terry Jones has argued that he would be in place in the company of a mercenary. I find this less persuasive than his hypothesis about the Knight himself as I do his comment on the Squire's fluting and will not repeat them here. Again, the equipment speaks of his character by metonymy: here is a man fastidious about his tools. He does not droop, but is upright and confident like his quality arrows.  Almost all the characters have their own point of vanity but his is not in his person: his close-cropped head contrasts with the Squire's curled locks. 

Monday, 9 November 2026

Trope

 A trope is what can be termed a figure of speech, when language is used not entirely literally.The devices that are normally considered to be tropes are metaphor, simile, metonymy, synecdoche, irony, personification, hyperbole and litotes. 

Synecdoche

 Synecdoche is a frequently used trope or figure of speech by which something or someone is referred to by one of its parts. "All hands on deck," calls the sailors, not just their hands to get to work. It is often regarded as a special form of metonymy, which I have defined in a separate post.

The General Prologue to the Canterbury Tales: an over view

 Chaucer's “The Canterbury Tales” is a fragment of the original proposition of two stories each on the road to Canterbury and two on the way home: only a few pilgrims tell even one tale. It is uncertain why this is but it would seem that the General Prologue is complete. This section should be distinguished from the individual prologues preceding the tales: it sets the scene and describes the pilgrims. Chaucer himself is one of them and he adopts the persona of a naif onlooker, whilst jokingly giving himself the tedious narrative of Sir Topas. In reality, he was a sophisticated and learned man, which we can deduce from his sharp and worldly perceptions as he writes. The central premise is unrealistic: they could not all have heard the narrations as they trooped together (with the clopping of hooves and the jingling of bridle bells) but it is accepted as a method of grouping narratives within a framework.

Chaucer opens with the meme of a description of Spring but adds an almost cinematographic element. His verse details the fresh awakening of nature, the relief that winter is past, a stirring into life mirrored by the restless desire that people have to go on a trip. (A modern equivalent would be a Disney-like film and customers booking their holiday). There are the visuals and sense of the showers, the auditory impact of the sounds of the birds, the feel of the breeze, the warmth of the sun on April 17th*, all giving the sense of vibrant activity and secular fun, as well as a holy intent for a few. Only some of the characters would seem to be there for the good of their souls but, at this stage, Chaucer is apparently uncritical.

When he embarks on the portraits, he varies his tone for each: most are satirised to some degree although, in the case of the ecclesiastics, it is the institution of the church as well as the character that is the target. They are designated by their trade or profession (their "degree" or station in life) whilst remaining highly individualised. I hope to investigate how the portraits are built up, looking at tropes that were recognised as figures of speech or "colours of rhetoric" in Chaucer's day. 

Chaucer's method is always to describe in the order of observation - not of visual memory. Memory tends to schematise whereas, when seeing someone in front of us, we notice details in random order. No two of them are portrayed from head to foot in paradigmatic mode: it is as if Chaucer is looking at each afresh and jotting down what he notices first, last and in between. This adds immediacy and vivaciousness, the lifelike presence of individuals, some of whom resonate down the centuries. Yet Chaucer includes details of their habits and background that could not be seen but only told to him - or even be the privilege of the omniscient narrator (at odds with his mask of innocence).

I now plan to analyse the main characters in future posts but will start with the Squire and the Yeoman together. On another blog, I have addressed the Knight with reference to Terry Jones' book and this can be read by using the Search box for "Knighthood in the Fourteenth Century" on my history blog.

https://onthebusesm.blogspot.com

* The date: Chaucer uses circumlocutio (a recognised rhetorical device which allows controlled long-windedness) to tell us that the date must be past the 11th April because of the position of the sun. In the Man of Law's Prologue, April 18th is given as the second day of the pilgrimage.

Sunday, 8 November 2026

John Donne: The Flea

 If you were to ask me which poem by John Donne, most exemplifies his special talents, I would cite "The Flea". Reading it we can appreciate his virtuoso skills, wit, use of a conceit, sense of drama and ability to evoke a situation in all its immediacy. There is eroticism and yet a train of thought and narrative. 

Two lovers are in an intimate position when a flea bites him and then her, thus mingling their bloods. Donne uses this mundane, even distasteful, occurrence to embark on a preposterous analogy, a conceit, between this and the sex that he wants to enjoy with her.

The first stanza sets this scene whilst implying her reasons for denying him: "losse of maidenhood," sin and shame.  With an erotically sly use of language, he points out that the creature is pampered and swollen with blood. 

Between this and the second stanza, the narrative moves forwards and shows that she is unconvinced by his (deliberately?) specious argument. She has raised her hand to squash the intruder as is seen when he begs her to "stay", adding the even more unlikely supposition that the flea now contains both their lives and that killing it would be triple murder. The exaggerated comparison gains pace when he uses metaphor (not simile) to state that this is now their marriage bed and temple. He slips in her further reason why their union cannot be consummated: her parents disapprove also. With virtuoso skill, he now makes the flea seem beautiful as it is "living walls of jet" and holy so that its extinction would be "sacrilege." The verse form has three rhyming lines concluding each stanza to emphasise his pleading although the iambic pentameters are maintained.

That changes to a brusque tetrameter at the start of the final stanza: "Cruell and sodaine, hast thou since.. " She has - dramatically - killed the flea (with her finger nail) which equally suddenly, is a mortal creature once again and, in his view, innocent. Far from being abashed, she is triumphant in her own actions. Although we have only his voice and point of view, she is  clearly realised, through his perspective, in masterly fashion. In the next few words, he would appear to capitulate: "'Tis true" but instantly switches the argument yet again. With Donne, we can never let our brains lie idle: there is always a thread of thought, often twisting, to be followed, closely intertwined with the emotion. Does she surrender? The answer lies in his confident use of "when" not "if" when he assures her there will be no more loss of honour in her yielding to him than there was in her being bitten.

There was a tradition of fleas being used (often jocularly) in erotic Renaissance literature because of the fact they could roam anywhere on the body. Donne turns this popular meme into a fresh and skilled narrative persuasion, using a conceit, drama, evocation of the attitude and actions of his lady and wit (meaning quickness of mind). By the end we know how the two people relate to each other. We can hazard a guess at the outcome since her refusal might have been no more serious than his bizarre reasoning. Perhaps they have both been enjoying the battle of wit and will as foreplay. After all, they were possibly already in bed. 


 



 

Satire

 Satire is a term much misused nowadays. It does not mean mere mockery, poking fun at something or someone, sneering at them or debunking them.

In true satire there is always a positive. By that I mean that the reader or viewer should be able to tell what the satirist does admire, trust or hold as ideal. 

Satire is the undermining of someone or something by humour, wit, irony, caricature, juxtaposition, ridicule or other methods. Yet, we should ask: what would NOT be the target of those arrows? It is an important question because much of English Literature, up to the Romantic period, was satirical and took as topics people and society. There was less emphasis on nature, emotion and the self - more on reason, morality and other human beings. Chaucer, Pope and Dryden wrote about contemporary life with a sceptical eye, so much so that Pope's invective requires extensive footnotes to appreciate exactly what he is saying.

An example of a clear and explicit positive can be found in Chaucer's General Prologue to the Canterbury Tales. Here he gives portraits of several ecclesiastical characters, mostly satirised except for one. The Prioress, the Monk, the Friar, the Summoner, the Pardoner and even the Clerk are treated with varying degrees of sly or overt criticism - but the Parson is Chaucer's representation of the true religious man. 

I have defined irony on earlier posts (use the Search button) and plan to examine the General Prologue in detail in future. Watch this space!

Thursday, 5 November 2026

Iago's true motive in "Othello"

 Coleridge famously described Iago's ruminations as "the motive-hunting of motiveless malignancy". There could be something in that as it is possible that Shakespeare was embodying the stock figure of Vice from the old Morality Plays. Yet it seems an unlikely fit in a drama that is domestically realistic - note Othello's homely list of his wife's accomplishments and pastimes, when he defends her virtue to Iago much later. 

Other reasons given are

being passed over in promotion by Cassio, an "arithmetician" who lacks his own military experience. This is more credible than the others which include:

 a spurious suspicion that Othello has slept with his own wife, Emilia;

an even more dubious one that Cassio has also cuckolded him with her;

racial hatred of Othello - but inexplicable why this should suddenly have surfaced

love of mischief for its own sake, which could be backed by the quotation earlier in the play, after the drunken brawl: "Pleasure and action make the hours seem short". (See the reference to the Auden view at the end of this post).

his own feelings for Desdemona - specious again as he rules out "absolute lust"

I take, as Iago's anchor motive, his saying of Cassio:

"He hath a daily beauty in his life

That makes me ugly".

Listen to the falling cadence in those words and they come across as the truth. With Shakespeare, who knew living drama on the stage, we must hear the lilt of the iambic pentameters (and Iago here speaks in blank verse) and respond to it. The next lines about being afraid of a reveal have quite a different tone of rationalisation.

Here I will go out on a limb and suggest that Iago, at a profound and unwilling level, also feels that Othello and Desdemona have that "daily beauty" in their lives. This is barely thinkable within his overt view of a man of colour - but Iago has witnessed the reconciliation with Desdemona after the storm.  He has heard and watched the rapturous greetings and the aria-like quality of their speeches, particularly Othello's. He must "set down the pegs that make this music" and create discord instead of harmony, by turning her "virtue into pitch." Meanwhile he resorts to debasing language whilst he plots the destruction of love and beauty.

For further reading and food for thought, I suggest W.H. Auden's essay: "The joker in the pack" in his collection, The Dyer's Hand. 


Wednesday, 4 November 2026

Sense and Sensibility: a different angle

 Sense and Sensibility was the first of Jane Austen's six major works to be published and it was originally an epistolary novel, written when she was about nineteen. The legacy of the letter format shows in the long speeches made by some characters, particularly Elinor, where she takes on a didactic tone. It could be argued that it is Jane Austen's only novel of ideas, where she reveals awareness of the growing ethos of Romanticism and fears its influence - whilst being drawn under its spell. 

It is accepted that Elinor represents sense or what we would call common sense, although she is not devoid of emotion. Marianne is the vehicle of sensibility - in modern terms sensitivity - although she can use her reason. They are not stereotypes. 

Perhaps the feeling of the novel is best expressed in Persuasion, Chapter 11:  "... she ventured to recommend a larger allowance of prose in his daily study." Poetry and emotion are all very well but the rationality and mundane nature of prose is to be respected. The paradox is that Marianne is - to many readers - a more appealing character than Elinor and one whose eventual marrying off to the flannel-waistcoated Colonel Brandon is a disappointment. 

Whilst Jane Austen never treats Elinor with irony and appreciates the need for decorum, sense and propriety in life, the actual writing also sympathises with her wilful sister, despite her dangerous and impulsive actions. It isn't as simple as head versus heart: we, as readers, receive the impression that the author is torn between two attitudes to life at the cusp of ideological change.

I am not arguing that there is no element of thoughtfulness in the other novels. Yet, Sense and Sensibility is governed by abstract ideas prevalent at the time: the theme is more obvious and embodied explicitly in the central characters. Although Jane Austen mocks Marianne's "transporting sensation" over the dead leaves that Elinor views in matter-of-fact fashion, she has created an endearing portrait. Which sister do we remember years after we have read the book?



Friday, 30 October 2026

John Donne and the compasses

Donne's poetry is remarkable for the way in which he combines reason with emotion:  even in his most passionate love poems, the reader cannot let her or his brain cells rest. There is always a thread of thought which must be followed if the poem is to be fully appreciated. 

Sometimes he extends his ideas to the extreme, a quality noticed by Dr. Johnson who commented on the Metaphysical poets: "If their conceits were far-fetched, they were often worth the carriage". By this he meant that there would be a truth at the end of the journey of understanding their unusual thought or fancy. In literary criticism now, the term, "conceit" is used to denote a comparison between two unlikely things, stretching credulity but expecting the reader to admire the ingenuity of the writer. 

The best example of this is Donne's poem, "A Valediction forbidding mourning", in which he argues, somewhat unconvincingly, that physical absence between true lovers is unimportant because they are "Inter-assured of the mind". Listing what will be missing (eyes, lips and hands) only makes the reader realise that he is trying to persuade  his partner not to mourn his departure - whilst being uncertain himself.

This sense is compounded by the ultimate motion in the image of the lovers as "stiffe twin compasses" which are two in one. She is the fixed foot which moves only when he does, leaning further outwards if he moves a greater distance away, growing "erect" when he returns. 

Yet, if you take a pair of compasses and enact the final stanza, it says the opposite. The conceit works against the emotion. The feeling is that the lovers will be reunited but rationality has them apart: her firmness and constancy cause him to draw his circle "just" and end where he began.  That means that he has joined up with his own trajectory and drawn a perfect circle - but is still apart from her. There are two different motions in those three stanzas: the first where the centre foot (her) draws the wandering one back to it; the second where it (she) stays firm, guiding his circle but ending with him still away from her.

My reading is that the persona of the speaker is doubtful of his own argument: the latent eroticism reveals that uncertainty - as does the final stanza of the compasses conceit. He fears that they could stay apart after his absence. 

Wednesday, 28 October 2026

Othello: The Temptation Scene

A ct 111 scene iii of Othello is often referred to as the Temptation Scene, although this is not a particularly good title. It is the lengthy scene, broken in the middle, in which Iago manipulates Othello into believing that his wife, Desdemona, is unfaithful to him with Cassio. I do not intend to examine Iago's villainous methods but to draw attention to two points in the dialogue. I will then argue against the reading that the eponymous hero's actions are governed primarily by jealousy. 

The first crux is the moment at which Othello is convinced (l. 210):

Iago: ... when she seem'd to shake and fear your looks,

She lov'd them most.

Othello:                    And so she did.

Iago:                                                   Why, go to then.

Well acted, the Moor's voice takes a downward cast on: "And so she did", to indicate that this is his moment of capitulation. If the broken line is taken as one, there is an extra iambic foot to give it resonance. It is the fact that Desdemona has been capable of deception in the past that convinces him. This revelation is his gnawing fear.

The second crux is his statement: "Othello's occupation's gone", preceded by a detailed mourning for the sounds and glories of war. This argues against the interpretation that his main obsession is jealousy. That, in itself, would not entail the abandonment of a thrilling and renowned career. 

Othello connects his wife's honour with his own: her virtue and his wartime laurels are one and the same. If she is unfaithful, he cannot be a true soldier. It is noticeable that Shakespeare has taken as his protagonist a military personage of high rank - not a royal. Also, the man who deceives him is a colleague and cannot be suspected of lying. In fact, Othello believes that Iago is holding back some details of Desdemona's infidelity out of a sense of comradeship in arms. Remember that when they had all survived the stormy crossing to Cyprus, Othello greets Desdemona: "O my fair warrior." As his faithful wife, she is an integral part of his honour as a soldier.

Although jealousy is a part of his motivation, it is Othello's loss of his identity as a leading soldier that affects him more. Note that it is Iago who puts the notion of "the green-ey'd monster into Othello's mind. That will poison the marriage and that is his aim.  


King Lear: the opening scene

 In a speech of the Chorus in Antigone, by Jean Anouilh, there are these lines:

"The spring is wound up tight. I will uncoil of itself. That is what is so convenient about tragedy. The least little turn of the wrist will do it."

One of the best examples of how this works occurs in the first scene of King Lear and the "turn of the wrist" is Cordelia's answer: "Nothing."

It is accepted that this refusal to play the game set up by Lear to award her the best share of his kingdom is what triggers the horrific chaos that follows. What is often overlooked is the exact wording of the question to which that is her answer. 

Lear does not merely ask her to state her love; his precise words are:

"what can you say to draw

A third more opulent than your sisters? Speak."

Although there is a line break, the requirement is for her to make an effusive speech in order to get more wealth. It is a request for more flattery to obtain more land - and that is what Cordelia cannot do. There is something of the tight-lipped schoolgirl about her and she is disgusted at her sisters' florid pronouncements but what she rebels against is the demand that she, too, should be meretricious. She rejects it at the level of the question itself.

Lear continues and underlines his message by stating that, "Nothing will come of nothing." If she does not speak, she will receive no land. Her response, that she loves him according to her bond, is not cold and heartless - since the concept of a bond ran very deep in the idea of a Chain of Being in which everything was held tightly its place in a hierarchy. She obeys him as King, loves him as father and honours him as an elderly man: that is profound and resonant. It is a triple and tenacious bond.

It could be argued that the spring of tragedy is uncoiled because of the wording of the question. Lear asks the one person who could truly express her love in the one way that she could not fulfil. 

Monday, 26 October 2026

Hamlet's delay

 Much has been written about why Hamlet delays in taking his revenge on his uncle for the murder of his father but I want to suggest a different approach - in outline. He is not a typical revenge tragedy hero. 

On one level Hamlet has perfectly rational grounds for not acting immediately after his encounter with the ghost: it might be an emissary of the devil and untrustworthy. Once he has tested its veracity by the play, The Mouse-trap, the king has his Swiss guards around him. The only opportunity is when Claudius is praying and - although it might be rationalisation - Hamlet does not want to send his uncle's soul to heaven. Then he is shipped off to England. 

The problem occurs, not because he procrastinates, but because he constantly draws attention to that fact. In effect, Hamlet keeps saying: "I am delaying. Why?" Without the four soliloquies, the play would be much more straightforward. It would be the drama of an appointed avenger who waits until all is clear but is killed himself when he finally acts. What Shakespeare gives us is much more complicated: a sick psyche and - arguably - the first European tragedy of character. Greek tragedy has the concept of a crime in the body politic, such as a murder, needing to be purged. (Denmark resembles Argos after the killing of Agamemnon). In our play, repeated disease imagery links the ailing mind of the eponymous character to the illness in the state. As a result of his inner malady, Hamlet is extreme in his reactions to his mother, (unable to leave her sinful guilt to heaven, as instructed), and to Ophelia. His view of life, man and woman is poisoned. The outcome is good destroyed along with evil. 

Contemporary audiences would have recognised melancholia, a disordered product of too much black bile, but the presentation of Hamlet's mind, soul and heart is more complex, modern and mysterious than that medical diagnosis. 

Thursday, 22 October 2026

Originality and authority

 Nowadays we value originality, the individual's novel thinking or being inspired with a new thought or image.

I make that statement less confidently than I would have done, even 5 years ago, because of the ubiquitous use of AI, which ensures that so much on the internet looks and reads the same. No sooner does a person ask to check a fact than AI offers to write a text or provide an image. I always tell it - quite bluntly - that I will use my own brain, photographs and images but many people accept. The result is a bland similarity that masks any unique personality, voice or idea. Rant over!

If we look at the Preamble to the Wife of Bath's Tale in Chaucer's  The Canterbury Tales, (not her portrait in the General Prologue), we see that she starts by distinguishing between experience and authority. By this she means that she has learned from the school of life rather than from recognised and revered texts. She continues - at length - to defend this position, interpreting classical and biblical references to her own end, the defence of her many marriages. Although she has denied the importance of authorities, she shows her own familiarity with them - but her gloss on them is undeniably humorous.. Had women written the texts, she claims, there would have been emphasis on the evil of men. Comic she may be - but she is right!

It was when her fifth husband, Jankin, (with whom she fell truly in love at her previous husband's funeral because of his shapely legs and feet) read to her from his book of wicked wives that she became incensed. The work was full of classical references to misbehaving women which enraged her. 

What this goes to show is that, until comparatively recently in historical terms, knowledge of the classics and the Bible was held in higher esteem than creative talent. Shakespeare borrowed many of his plots and this was not considered to be plagiarism. 

Perhaps it was Romanticism that altered that sense of priority, with its emphasis on the individual and inspiration, like an Aeolian harp, gifting a writer with ideas. Originality became important - let us not squander it by laziness and copying from AI. 

Monday, 19 October 2026

A vital speech in Shakespeare

 Troilus and Cressida is not Shakespeare's best known play nor is it his most accessible. Yet it contains one speech which reveals much contemporary (and previous) thinking and belief. Ulysses describes in detail the chaos which would result from an essential hierarchy being destroyed, the widely held view of world order that I (following Pope, Lovejoy and Tillyard) have termed the Great Chain of Being in a previous post.

Strictly, the speech should be set in its dramatic and historical context with Ulysses having a political agendum concerning Achilles - and so any decoding should bear that in mind. He delivers the relevant part of this oration in Act I scene iii beginning at line 83: "Degree being vizarded" and continues until l. 134: "pale and bloodless emulation".  

In the main section of the speech, he orates about the consequences of degree being overturned. This would be like the steps of a ladder being disassembled and chaos resulting. The sun, Sol, is properly like a king of the planets, but, if this position of power were lost and concord thereby disrupted, the earth would be subject to sea storms, earthquakes and all manner of horrors. The microcosm of human life is reflected reciprocally by the macrocosm of the heavens, which is why celestial portents were so feared, in case they heralded a disaster. (Note the derivation of that word). The imagery is of the discord caused when a string is untuned. 

Ulysses then declaims about the loss of degree or hierarchy in human society which would cause total disorder and render "peaceful commerce" unworkable, mirrored by the waters overwhelming dry land.  This leads to the crucial section where justice falls apart, sons murder fathers and any moral sense of right and wrong is no more. Man would become akin to an animal, a "universal wolf" because he would be driven by appetite, will and power with no restraints set by reason, the faculty which should separate humanity from beasts. The result would be uncontrollable competition. Overall, it is a terrifying picture - but one with a political aim.

I will leave you to read this speech for yourself and consider how the concept, although special to one situation, can shed light on other texts: King Lear's abdication would be one complex example. 

Monday, 12 October 2026

Using a Thesaurus - for students

I have already posted about banning words like upset and incredibly in a literary essay. If I had my way they'd be made illegal in everyday life! That's because they are so ubiquitous and bland that they remove all the process of thinking how to write or talk sense. AI constantly says something is incredible when it wants you to believe it. Nonsense! We don't use AI to help us to write though, do we?

What else can be used instead of the adjective upset? If I turn to Roget's Thesaurus I find plenty of other expressions, some of which I have formed from the verbs given. (Not alternatives because that means one of two). Here are some of them:

troubled, embarrassed, discomfited, worried, afflicted, distressed, traumatised, harrowed, shocked, appalled, frightened, distraught, horrified, pained, wounded, nettled, embittered, offended, tormented, vexed, depressed.

If you feel confident about their meaning, tone and register (whether formal or slang for example), go ahead and use one of them, storing it in your memory. If you are uncertain, wait until you have encountered the term a few times in your general reading. There are also dictionaries of synonyms and antonyms that can help to widen your working vocabulary range. You want your essays to stand out from the crowd and a more precise use of words will do it. 

Tuesday, 29 September 2026

The Fall of Man

Of man's first disobedience, and the fruit

Of that forbidden tree whose mortal taste

Brought death into the word and all our woe ...

These are the opening lines of Milton's epic poem Paradise Lost which cannot be understood without a working knowledge of the story of the Fall of Man. Not only Milton, but other authors allude to the concept - as do many artists. We sometimes refer to "forbidden fruit."

The narrative is that Eve, partner of Adam in the perfect Garden of Eden, was tempted by Satan, disguised as a serpent, to eat the fruit of the Tree of Knowledge. Although this was forbidden by God, she persuaded Adam to do the same. From being immortal and without sin, they then became both mortal and sinful, his act being known as Original Sin. It induced shame which led them to cover their genitals with leaves. They were finally banished from the Garden by St. Michael. The fruit is often represented as an apple and the leaves as fig leaves.

I failed to find a verifiable photograph of the Garden and so, here is my impression. St. Michael was not wearing the eponymous underwear of the erstwhile famous brand at the time. Nor a fig leaf.

Satan wanted vengeance on God for hurling him, then an angel, Lucifer, bearer of light, out of heaven down to Hell because he had rebelled. After consultation with the other fallen angels, he decided that the best way was to attack God's newly created humans. His sin was Pride or hubris, the worst of the 7 Deadly sins. (Soldiers in W.W.1 sang of a match as a Lucifer). The council of fallen angels, now devils, in Hell was known as Pandemonium (all the devils) a word we still use today. Pride, as we all know, goes before a fall.

Mankind, instead of being immortal as before, now encountered Death, until given the chance to regain everlasting life by following God's incarnated son, Jesus. In Paradise Regained Milton covered that too. At length. 

These are doubtless great works but the diction is heavily Latinate. Dr. Johnson remarked of Paradise Lost that "none ever wished it longer than it is" and that "the lack of human interest is always felt". Well said, Samuel.

Wednesday, 23 September 2026

How to structure and write a literature essay

This post will give you a basic structure for a one-hour literature essay on one of your set examination texts. It is: introduction, 3 or 4 main paragraphs, conclusion.

Before you start, repeat to yourself: relevance, relevance, relevance. However brilliant an idea may be, it will gain no marks at all if it does not answer the question exactly as set.

Even if you feel pressed for time, read the question carefully and give it a few minutes' thought before writing anything. Then construct one sentence (or a couple of shorter ones) which answer it directly, You can jot this down on rough paper - if allowed - or it can be the first sentence of your essay, in the introduction.

Let us take the question: Analyse the theme of madness in King Lear. (Search for my separate post on the correct way of punctuating, although you can use quotation marks even for full titles in handwriting). Your overarching sentence for the whole essay might be:

"The theme of madness in King Lear is closely allied to that of folly and is embodied in three characters: King Lear himself, the Fool and Poor Tom. Each is different and has his own language".

You have shown that you can relate madness to other concepts but do NOT go on to write about folly except to mention it briefly. The last sentence shows that you are aware of how a writer achieves his effects. Showing how will gain you top grades. 

Fortunately, the structure of paragraphs is there: one for each character.  A paragraph must have a key sentence: "The Fool's apparent madness contains sharp wisdom about the folly of Lear's actions because he is licensed to say what others dare not". You then expand on that point with a further explanation backed by quotations or close reference, paying attention to his unique manner of expression. If you cannot remember a quotation, do not invent it. The examiner knows the text inside out! Instead quote a word or two and paraphrase. To summarise: each paragraph has a leading key sentence, expansion and examples by quotation or close reference. Do the same for the other characters.

The conclusion can be a round up of what you have said or a new perception - but still relevant. It could be that sane Edgar in the sub-plot is also Poor Tom in the main plot, with his assumed madness. A different point could be that madness is connected to the theme of insight and blindness.

Extra tips: do not use AI to help you to write your homework essays. That bland, impersonal style is instantly recognisable and you will find yourself adopting it. Use the language that you would to a respected older person, not pompous but direct. Never use "upset" or "incredibly" and there is no need to say "I think". If the question seems impossibly difficult, do what you can with it. Schools will complain and the moderators will adjust their marking. 

Good luck and may you get Top Marks!

Tuesday, 22 September 2026

ONLY - have fun with the Bishop and the bun

 It is vital to place the word only correctly in your sentence. That position is usually just before the word it refers to or qualifies.

To see what i mean, take this simple sentence.

The Bishop gave the baboon a bun.

Now pop the word only before each word in turn.

I know you can do it by yourself - but I want to have fun also.

Only the Bishop gave the baboon a bun.

The only Bishop gave the baboon a bun.

The Bishop only gave the baboon a bun.

It's even more fun reading the sentences aloud. The last one should have a deeply apologetic tone because clearly the baboon had suffered as a result of its treat. Now carry on by yourself.

Note to any teachers reading this: your pupils will love it.

Monday, 21 September 2026

The Great Chain of Being

The concept of a chain of all creation, firmly in place and indisputable was widely upheld in the Middle Ages and through to Shakespeare.

It maintained that there is a rightful hierarchy which must not be broken and it is the exact opposite of our modern egalitarian view of life.

At the top was God and below Him came the angels. Man was next and was considered less spiritual than those above but with a capacity for reason which kept him above the category below him, animals. Plants followed and at the bottom were minerals. 

Within these groups there was also a ladder which makes quite comical reading nowadays when we do not pay attention to the exact position of prawns in a paradigm of life.



Sunday, 20 September 2026

Kennings and Homeric epithets

An Anglo-Saxon kenning is a descriptive pfrase which replaces the noun: 

The ship sailed over the whale-road.


A Homeric epithet is an adjectival phrase which adds to the noun:

The ship sailed over the wine-dark sea. It usually has two words: bright-eyed; rosy fingered.

Saturday, 19 September 2026

Two words you must not use in a literary essay.

 Upset and incredibly are inappropriate in formal writing. Upset is too colloquial and bland and incredibly means the opposite of what it says.