Single inverted commas

Although it is usual to enclose a word under discussion in single inverted commas, I have chosen instead to emphasise it in red to prevent confusion with apostrophes.
Showing posts with label John Donne. Show all posts
Showing posts with label John Donne. Show all posts

Sunday, 8 November 2026

John Donne: The Flea

 If you were to ask me which poem by John Donne, most exemplifies his special talents, I would cite "The Flea". Reading it we can appreciate his virtuoso skills, wit, use of a conceit, sense of drama and ability to evoke a situation in all its immediacy. There is eroticism and yet a train of thought and narrative. 

Two lovers are in an intimate position when a flea bites him and then her, thus mingling their bloods. Donne uses this mundane, even distasteful, occurrence to embark on a preposterous analogy, a conceit, between this and the sex that he wants to enjoy with her.

The first stanza sets this scene whilst implying her reasons for denying him: "losse of maidenhood," sin and shame.  With an erotically sly use of language, he points out that the creature is pampered and swollen with blood. 

Between this and the second stanza, the narrative moves forwards and shows that she is unconvinced by his (deliberately?) specious argument. She has raised her hand to squash the intruder as is seen when he begs her to "stay", adding the even more unlikely supposition that the flea now contains both their lives and that killing it would be triple murder. The exaggerated comparison gains pace when he uses metaphor (not simile) to state that this is now their marriage bed and temple. He slips in her further reason why their union cannot be consummated: her parents disapprove also. With virtuoso skill, he now makes the flea seem beautiful as it is "living walls of jet" and holy so that its extinction would be "sacrilege." The verse form has three rhyming lines concluding each stanza to emphasise his pleading although the iambic pentameters are maintained.

That changes to a brusque tetrameter at the start of the final stanza: "Cruell and sodaine, hast thou since.. " She has - dramatically - killed the flea (with her finger nail) which equally suddenly, is a mortal creature once again and, in his view, innocent. Far from being abashed, she is triumphant in her own actions. Although we have only his voice and point of view, she is  clearly realised, through his perspective, in masterly fashion. In the next few words, he would appear to capitulate: "'Tis true" but instantly switches the argument yet again. With Donne, we can never let our brains lie idle: there is always a thread of thought, often twisting, to be followed, closely intertwined with the emotion. Does she surrender? The answer lies in his confident use of "when" not "if" when he assures her there will be no more loss of honour in her yielding to him than there was in her being bitten.

There was a tradition of fleas being used (often jocularly) in erotic Renaissance literature because of the fact they could roam anywhere on the body. Donne turns this popular meme into a fresh and skilled narrative persuasion, using a conceit, drama, evocation of the attitude and actions of his lady and wit (meaning quickness of mind). By the end we know how the two people relate to each other. We can hazard a guess at the outcome since her refusal might have been no more serious than his bizarre reasoning. Perhaps they have both been enjoying the battle of wit and will as foreplay. After all, they were possibly already in bed. 


 



 

Friday, 30 October 2026

John Donne and the compasses

Donne's poetry is remarkable for the way in which he combines reason with emotion:  even in his most passionate love poems, the reader cannot let her or his brain cells rest. There is always a thread of thought which must be followed if the poem is to be fully appreciated. 

Sometimes he extends his ideas to the extreme, a quality noticed by Dr. Johnson who commented on the Metaphysical poets: "If their conceits were far-fetched, they were often worth the carriage". By this he meant that there would be a truth at the end of the journey of understanding their unusual thought or fancy. In literary criticism now, the term, "conceit" is used to denote a comparison between two unlikely things, stretching credulity but expecting the reader to admire the ingenuity of the writer. 

The best example of this is Donne's poem, "A Valediction forbidding mourning", in which he argues, somewhat unconvincingly, that physical absence between true lovers is unimportant because they are "Inter-assured of the mind". Listing what will be missing (eyes, lips and hands) only makes the reader realise that he is trying to persuade  his partner not to mourn his departure - whilst being uncertain himself.

This sense is compounded by the ultimate motion in the image of the lovers as "stiffe twin compasses" which are two in one. She is the fixed foot which moves only when he does, leaning further outwards if he moves a greater distance away, growing "erect" when he returns. 

Yet, if you take a pair of compasses and enact the final stanza, it says the opposite. The conceit works against the emotion. The feeling is that the lovers will be reunited but rationality has them apart: her firmness and constancy cause him to draw his circle "just" and end where he began.  That means that he has joined up with his own trajectory and drawn a perfect circle - but is still apart from her. There are two different motions in those three stanzas: the first where the centre foot (her) draws the wandering one back to it; the second where it (she) stays firm, guiding his circle but ending with him still away from her.

My reading is that the persona of the speaker is doubtful of his own argument: the latent eroticism reveals that uncertainty - as does the final stanza of the compasses conceit. He fears that they could stay apart after his absence.