The Monk is the first of the male ecclesiastics to be portrayed and he is treated comparatively sympathetically here by Chaucer, being appealing in physical appearance and not depicted as cheating people face to face.
He is introduced as a fine fellow whose duty was to look after the estates of his monastery, the church being rich in land. This meant he had to ride out but he used this as an excuse for hunting, which was a passion of his. This gives an ironic twist to the claim that he was worthy of being an abbot, since he was exceeding his role by engaging in worldly pursuits. However, a certain shrewdness was necessary for him to carry out his tasks.
He owned many fine horses and the one he rode as a pilgrim had loudly jingling bridle bells. This is metonymy, whereby the health and vigour of the man is conveyed through something connected to him, his top condition, noticeable mount. Bells on a bridle were aspirational.
He was Prior to a strict subordinate religious house but he let the old-fashioned rules lapse and preferred the modern outlook. Here Chaucer captures a turning point in Medieval life. A vibrant phrase, "pulled hen" (plucked), captures his disdain for the Monk's belief that a hunter cannot be holy or that a monk outside his cloister is like a fish out of water. He disposes of any authoritative barriers to his worldly pleasures. The striking rhyme "cloystre/oystre" almost sounds like his derisive scoffing.
The next line: "And I seyde his opinioun was good" shows Chaucer using his persona of naif pilgrim to invite us to question the morality of a churchman who flouts the principles of asceticism and religious teaching so readily. The technique sharpens when the narrator takes on the voice of the character arguing that studiousness does no good and neither does hard toil. He derides St. Augustine and the scorn can be heard in the rhythm whilst he defends his disobedience by claiming that acceptance of the rules does not help anybody. The use of "therefore" suggests - erroneously - that it follows logically for the Monk to be a hard rider, owning swift greyhounds and dedicated to hunting hares, no matter what it cost. Here Chaucer, the narrator, is criticising indirectly but more strongly as the code of poverty is abandoned.
A sudden switch returns us to the present onlooker, observing face to face rather than recounting what he has learned. His eye alights on the grey fur trim on the Monk's sleeves, the finest skins in the country. Another visual detail is his love-brooch, skilfully made. Up goes the watchful eye to the shiny bald head and face, oily - but not unattractive because he is stout and in good condition. His eyes are prominent and active in a head that glows like a furnace under a cauldron. Down we go now to his quality, supple boots and outwards to his fine horse: the narrator's eye roves constantly noticing this and that. The Monk is handsome and vibrant, not colourless (like a person wasted away by torment), enjoying a roasted fat swan best: the rhyme goost/roost makes the juxtaposed contrast stand out. The portrait ends quite abruptly with the mention of the type of horse he was riding - but the rhyme goes forwards to the next pilgrim with "berye/merye".
Summary and method. The Monk is rich, ample, expansive and pleasure-loving. He is the opposite of meanness and dryness: he shines, glows, steams and jangles. His belongings are of good quality and he has the feel of fresh air about him, not the cloister. These attributes, whilst appealing, are not religious: oblique criticism underlies the whole portrait. Yet some of the reproach is directed at the church for condoning such worldliness, even in a man whose duties are somewhat secular. We have the prototype method of giving the outline shape of the figure with details of features, clothing, colour (quite neutral), belongings, habits and, in this case almost the speaking voice along with the noise of bells.
The portrait shows one of the best examples of Chaucer's use of his innocently observing persona with his apparent total trust in the Monk's values and opinions.
No comments:
Post a Comment